Shared leads vs your own leads: the math for an electrical shop
Lead services are a fast way to fill a slow week. The question is what each booked job really costs you, and whether you are building something you own. Here is the math, with a worked example. The example numbers are made up to show the method; put your own numbers in.
The one number that matters: cost per booked job
For any source of work, the honest number is:
cost per booked job = what you spent ÷ jobs you actually booked
Not cost per lead. A lead you never reach, or that three other shops also called, costs the same as one you book.
Worked example (illustration only)
Say a shop buys 40 shared leads in a month.
| Shared leads (example) | |
|---|---|
| Leads bought | 40 |
| Price per lead | $X |
| Leads reached on the phone | 24 (60%) |
| Jobs booked | 6 (25% of those reached) |
| Cost per booked job | 40 × $X ÷ 6 |
Now the same shop's own calls from its Google profile and website for the month:
| Own calls (example) | |
|---|---|
| Monthly marketing cost | $Y |
| Calls from Google and the site | 30 |
| Jobs booked | 12 (40%; callers chose you, so more of them book) |
| Cost per booked job | $Y ÷ 12 |
Work both out with your real numbers. Two things usually show up:
- Shared leads cost the same every month. Stop paying and the leads stop.
- Own calls get cheaper per job over time, because the profile, reviews and pages you build keep working. Month 1 is the most expensive month; it is not the typical one.
What to track so the math is real
- A separate tracking number (or at least a "how did you hear about us" question) for each source.
- Every job tagged to the source that brought it in, including repeat customers.
- Booked jobs and the job value, not just calls.
Without this, every source looks good or bad depending on who you ask. With it, you can decide where each dollar goes.
When shared leads still make sense
When you are new to an area, when you need volume fast for a new crew, or for job types you want to test before building pages for them. Use them as a top-up, and keep building the source you own.
How we report it
Our monthly report shows calls, leads and booked jobs by source, so cost per booked job is a number you can see, not a guess. See Call tracking and reporting.
Example figures are illustrations, not results from any client. This guide is general information, not a promise of any number of calls or jobs. Reviewed November 19, 2026.